By Categories: Polity

Receive Daily Updates

Stay updated with current events, tests, material and UPSC related news


The official launch of the Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (ABDM) started an initiative that will give every citizen a unique digital health ID, linked to a personal health record (PHR). The ID will also be linked to the Aadhaar.

The process of assigning these health IDs started months ago when individuals using the Aadhaar to sign up for vaccinations on the CoWin app were assigned Digital Health IDs by default.

It is hoped the ABDM will significantly improve the efficiency, effectiveness, and transparency of health service delivery.

Someone with a health ID and PHR will be able to store personal medical history digitally (including prescriptions, diagnostic reports, discharge summaries, etc), access it, and share it as required. This can, for example, be of benefit to a patient with a medical issue while travelling.

Similarly, it will allow for the seamless transfer of patients across health care facilities. Health insurance providers will also find it useful for more efficient service delivery.

For health ID creation through the mobile or the Aadhaar, the beneficiary will be asked to share details of the name, year of birth, gender, address, and mobile number/Aadhaar. However, there are serious concerns about such digital systems in key areas of privacy and consent, particularly because India does not have a personal data protection law.

Reports indicate over 125 million people — anybody who used the Aadhaar to sign up for the CoWin app — has been assigned a health ID by default. Their consent was not explicitly sought, though it might have been hidden in the fine print of permission for CoWin.

This is not an auspicious beginning in terms of consent and privacy. The security features of the PHR servers where the data will be recorded are also quite hazy.

By definition, millions of individuals and multiple different agencies, institutions, and stakeholders will seek access to this data and leakages can prove damaging. It should be possible for users to opt out of the health ID and ADBM and still receive health care.

Also, user-consent for every granular access of the PHR and of the demographic data should ideally be built in. The official website says users will be allowed to permanently delete, or deactivate their PHR and health ID, if they desire.

This would mean all demographic details would be erased. The devil will be in the detail of this inbuilt feature, but it will surely take care of some consent issues.

The health ID will collate data and create a repository. This can, in theory, lead to better health care services and also aid in the creation of better health policies if that data is analysed for trends.

But Aarogya Setu and the CoWin app, and their efficacy in practice, raise questions about some basic issues. For instance, those without smartphones found it difficult to get onboard and exclusivity could be a problem here as well.

More worrying, despite the obsession with gathering data, the pandemic was not efficiently tackled. Many died due to lack of oxygen, and the vaccination programme moved by stops and starts due to the late procurement of vaccines.

Data collection is necessary to deliver more efficient services, but that in itself is not sufficient to assure such services if attention is not paid to the basics.


 

Share is Caring, Choose Your Platform!

Recent Posts

  • Darknet

    Definition:

    Darknet, also known as dark web or darknet market, refers to the part of the internet that is not indexed or accessible through traditional search engines. It is a network of private and encrypted websites that cannot be accessed through regular web browsers and requires special software and configuration to access.

    The darknet is often associated with illegal activities such as drug trafficking, weapon sales, and hacking services, although not all sites on the darknet are illegal.

    Examples:

    Examples of darknet markets include Silk Road, AlphaBay, and Dream Market, which were all shut down by law enforcement agencies in recent years.

    These marketplaces operate similarly to e-commerce websites, with vendors selling various illegal goods and services, such as drugs, counterfeit documents, and hacking tools, and buyers paying with cryptocurrency for their purchases.

    Pros :

    • Anonymity: Darknet allows users to communicate and transact with each other anonymously. Users can maintain their privacy and avoid being tracked by law enforcement agencies or other entities.
    • Access to Information: The darknet provides access to information and resources that may be otherwise unavailable or censored on the regular internet. This can include political or sensitive information that is not allowed to be disseminated through other channels.
    • Freedom of Speech: The darknet can be a platform for free speech, as users are able to express their opinions and ideas without fear of censorship or retribution.
    • Secure Communication: Darknet sites are encrypted, which means that communication between users is secure and cannot be intercepted by third parties.
    •  

    Cons:

    • Illegal Activities: Many darknet sites are associated with illegal activities, such as drug trafficking, weapon sales, and hacking services. Such activities can attract criminals and expose users to serious legal risks.
    • Scams: The darknet is a hotbed for scams, with many fake vendors and websites that aim to steal users’ personal information and cryptocurrency. The lack of regulation and oversight on the darknet means that users must be cautious when conducting transactions.
    • Security Risks: The use of the darknet can expose users to malware and other security risks, as many sites are not properly secured or monitored. Users may also be vulnerable to hacking or phishing attacks.
    • Stigma: The association of the darknet with illegal activities has created a stigma that may deter some users from using it for legitimate purposes.